Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

A couple of weeks ago, we had an interesting lesson on the Fall of Mankind. A number of things were brought up that interested me. One was the difference between sin and transgression.

The way I see it, a transgression is the breaking of a law, while sin is knowingly breaking the law and willfully disobeying God. By this definition, a sin is a transgression, but a transgression isn’t necessarily a sin. This fits nicely with 1 John 3:4, which I’ve heard numerous times from those unfriendly to the Church to make out the Fall to be a horrible thing, something that we as a Church try to explain as something necessary and beautiful.  They were innocent (2 Nephi 2:23, Genesis 2:25), and therefore their transgression wasn’t so bad.

But my real question isn’t the degree to which Adam transgressed. My question is that which has been asked so many times before me; Why did God make the path to a necessary mortality through a transgression of the commandments of God?

Some have theorized that God was testing them to see if they would be obedient for a period of time, and that later he would command them to partake of the fruit.  This doesn’t make sense to me for a few of reasons: 1) Such a test wouldn’t seem to have any bearing on anything temporal or spiritual.  They still would have been required to enter the lone and dreary world where they would be subject to sin and temptation.  2) I don’t believe God would command someone to do something that would result in separation from him.  All of his commandments are designed to bring us closer.  3) A stronger argument than anything I could offer comes from 2 Nephi 2:22, where it seems to teach that if there had been no transgression, Adam and Eve would still be hanging out in the Garden of Eden.

I offer what I believe is the truer answer.  God knew that the experiences we needed to grow and become gods ourselves required a test of mortality and separation from God.  But by his own laws, he can’t simply remove himself from us.  We have to transgress to part from him.  He set up a law that could be broken in order for them to separate themselves.  Here’s the part that some might consider dangerous.  He allowed them to make a decision that put them in the fallen state necessary for growth via transgression.  Some may believe this to be borderline blasphemous.  I knew a missionary who put it this way: “It sounds like God set them up to get screwed.”  I don’t see it that way.

You see, God knows the beginning from the end.  He doesn’t ever command someone to sin, but he knows they’re going to do it.  So he uses others’ choices to further his own ends.  Take the crucifixion of Christ for example.  In 2 Nephi 10:3 it explains that it was necessary for Christ to live among the Jews, because they were the only ones wicked enough to crucify their Messiah.  He used the bad choices of others to complete his Son’s atonement.

But in the case of Adam and Eve, God didn’t even allow them to sin.  From certain scriptures (Moses 4:14, and others that seem to imply such), we know that children can trangress the law.  Heck, if you punish your 3-year old child for coloring on the wall, you know this.  They break the law, and there are temporal consequences, like time-out.  Nevertheless, they are innocent, and are therefore not eternally accountable for their decisions.  Adam and Eve’s innocence allowed them to pay for their decisions temporally (because it was merely transgression), and yet remain unstained from sin (see Moroni 8:8, 20, 22 that it still required Christ to atone for children, which he did because of their innocence).

Adam and Eve were innocent, and therefore they fulfilled God’s plan by transgressing the law, and yet God didn’t cause them to sin in the process.

I imagine that some readers (if I still have any after my absence) might have qualms with this doctrine.  I invite any comments, as this is a merely a question and a theoretical answer.

2 Responses to Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

  1. Vintage buses for hire from Yorkshire Heritage Bus

    You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!

  2. Clare Walters

    You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!

  3. gdrnmqsxe

    the ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments
    gdrnmqsxe http://www.gzr73p53t07ex4585j7e2p34pdvk56cas.org/

  4. Cheap Jerseys From China

    Rule 1: Know your prospective customers. If you are unsuccessful, look for furniture that are as similar as possible.Aubameyang has now scored 30 goals this season for Dortmund. Anything from celebrity news, hobbies to house cleaning tips.Make A Statement With Your Multi – Level Marketing Through These HintsMake A Statement With Your Multi – Level Marketing Through These HintsMarch 5, 2014 | Author: Garry Forsyth | Posted in BusinessThe forex market can offer a great way to earn steady returns, but you don’t want to just jump in blindly without knowing what you are doing.
    Cheap Jerseys From China

  5. Cheap NFL Jerseys China Free Shipping

    “. It usually doesn’t cost much and can be very beneficial if you want to have individual balances.You may want to take just a few classes at first to get used to your new schedules and lifestyles. These technicians will maintain the server where the information is kept as well as repair any minor problems before they turn into major ones.Speak with a enterprise attorney to determine what regulations you may have to deal with when commencing a work from your home company.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China Free Shipping

  6. Cheap NFL Jerseys China

    Sensors To begin you need to confirm the presence of receptors in cameras.”Kershaw has not pitched for the team since June 26 because of a herniated disk in his lower back. A happy medium between the two will be great so that your blog gets pOwnership Backs John Farrell Ben Cherington In Boston RealGM WiretapBoston Red Sox owner John W. “With the time he’s missed, my guess would be the next step would be a Minor League assignment. Testing out new things will bring in the interest of the latest buyers and enhance profit.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China

  7. Wholesale Jerseys Cheap

    Avoid comparisons entirely to avoid sending yourself off course. Many of the tools needed to fix an Xbox 360 E74 are normal household items. This will allow you to network with other individuals inside your discipline and to create a good name for on your own. During the Nazi war, modern Art was unappreciated and banned by the Nazis. Also, you will see only one red light flashing and it will be in the right bottom side of the ring.
    Wholesale Jerseys Cheap

  8. Wholesale Jerseys

    Learning about your industry can be a great way to start succeeding with it.You simply will not learn how good something diffrent most likely is should you do exactly the same thing every single day.Customers who do weekend shopping are the main target for any business, so providing them with various weekend offers can attract those clients to make them to see and buy your furniture. It also provides an interactive platform for enthusiasts to post information or news related to Dutch Arts and Netherlands Cultural Events.Speak with a enterprise attorney to determine what regulations you may have to deal with when commencing a work from your home company.
    Wholesale Jerseys

  9. Wholesale Nike NFL Jerseys China

    This denotes that the United States is indeed a second home for Dutch art and culture. Author Resource: Josie Smith is the author of this article on Dutch Arts Calendar.John Farrell sent a message to the team by benching Sandoval for one game on Thursday against the Braves. Other single parents may have had personal experience with different day cares and help you make a decision. Having natural light, plants, and trees around can also relax a student so that they can focus more on their studies.
    Wholesale Nike NFL Jerseys China

  10. http://www.cheapnbajerseyschinashop.com/

    “Kershaw has not pitched for the team since June 26 because of a herniated disk in his lower back. Distinguishing the socio economic class, gender, and age group of your perceived market will help you come up with the complimentary item that will influence them to buy. Although this may seem tedious at first, it will pay off big time. Save time for both of you by politely rejecting the application over the phone. From Boise campuses to St.

  11. Brad Daugherty Jersey

    You can get your web marketing business to the next level. Cultivate a relaxed feel in your grip and enjoy the natural “chill” response from breathing properly. Plenty of people don't really wish to share this info so they fail to get the loan.5 games back in the National League East.Yong Kuo is a stay home dad since 2010.
    Brad Daugherty Jersey

  12. Fernando Manchester City Jersey UK

    Before getting a high cost pay day loan, consider trying to borrow money from family or friends.com report. And there are people with what is known as micro penis; a penis can be considered to be micro penis if it shorter than 2. If you can't pay a pay day loan, try getting an individual loan from a bank as opposed to paying the pay day loan using their refinancing option. This specific generally ensures that a person can possess your individual portable desktop computer correct at the the company of both hands! Think about the limitless opportunities of being able to carry close to your current home computer in a lunchbox/briefcase made enclosure.
    Fernando Manchester City Jersey UK

  13. Tim Hardaway Jersey UK

    A lot of things that can help you are available, you just need to increase the risk for first step.com.Tanaka Yankees Wanted Me Most Relieved To Have Deal RealGM WiretapMasahiro Tanaka chose to sign with the New York Yankees because they appreciated him the most among the interested parties.Utley Takes Grounders At Third Base RealGM WiretapChase Utley is considering playing third base again, according to an ESPN. A shoe that is too tight can cause blisters at the toes and toenail problems.
    Tim Hardaway Jersey UK

  14. Tim Thomas Jersey

    Unhappily, this can result in the overuse of certain muscles and the overall action of your swing is not as relaxed or effective. If barefoot running is something you would like to try, make sure to gradually work into it.An essential tip to consider in relation to community advertising is to make yourself as public as possible.The More Relaxed the Better Sometimes, when we are anxious about a shot, we can squeeze just that little bit too hard. Since building a house is usually a major decision, it is imperative for a person to have the right information and guidance to assist him in choosing the best builders to work with.
    Tim Thomas Jersey

  15. Ivory

    bookmarked!!, I really like your site.

  16. http://einstafollowers.com/

    Hmm it looks like your site ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I
    guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog.

    I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to
    the whole thing. Do you have any tips for inexperienced blog writers?
    I’d certainly appreciate it.

  17. http://www.aibifuli.top/home.php?mod=space&uid=51255&do=profile&from=space

    Great goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely wonderful.

    I actually like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you are stating and the way in which
    you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to keep
    it sensible. I cant wait to read much more from
    you. This is actually a great website. http://www.aibifuli.top/home.php?mod=space&uid=51255&do=profile&from=space

  18. dog care centre singapore

    Have you ever considered creating an e-book or guest authoring on other blogs?
    I have a blog centered on the same topics you discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information. I know my subscribers would value your work.
    If you are even remotely interested, feel free to send me an e mail.

  19. Clare Walters

    Hey There. I found your blog using msn. This is an extremely well written article. I will be sure to bookmark it and return to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the post. I will definitely comeback.

  20. massage therapy chair

    Hi there are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m trying to get started and create
    my own. Do you need any html coding knowledge to make your own blog?
    Any help would be greatly appreciated!

  21. Angel Brides Wedding Dresses and Bridal Gowns

    I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new information.

  22. http://x1host.de/index/users/view/id/73397

    Your style is very unique compared to other people I’ve read stuff from.
    Thank you for posting when you’ve got the opportunity, Guess I will just
    book mark this page.

  23. Cheap NFL Jerseys China

    Ranked 220 overall with 5.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China

  24. ?elik A??nd?r?c? Grit

    the ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

  25. Cheap Jerseys From China

    They didn’t get all the big names they wanted in free agency — with Devin McCourty and Randall Cobb going elsewhere — but Julius Thomas, Jared Odrick, Davon House and Jermey Parnell were young free agent signings with upside.
    Cheap Jerseys From China

  26. ??????????


  27. Wholesale Cheap Jerseys

    Even if it is just a simple household or personal item, it still can be promotive if it can be used along with the promoted product. Having said that, keeping in front of the group indicates retaining on the top of new clients suggestions.. Various artists are keen on having themselves featured on the Dutch Arts Calendar of Events since these are platforms for them to make a kill on their art pieces. Using social networks has the potential to put you miles ahead of everyone else in the network marketing business.
    Wholesale Cheap Jerseys

  28. Wholesale Baseball Jerseys China

    Your downline is an essential resource of information, so don’t forget about them once they sign up under you. Even if it just clears your space and organizes your life, there is a benefit to feng shui. Students of the Boise campus are proud of their school.Calculate what you spend a month by nine to figure out what you’d need for an emergency. Despite the fact that there are numerous ways to earn money on the internet, picking the perfect way to make money online requires careful thought and frequently forces some trial and error.
    Wholesale Baseball Jerseys China

  29. Cheap Nike Jerseys

    In both cases, the fundamental goal is to find people and that is where a strong online social network can really shine. The popularity of the Netherlands Cultural Events has attracted many art enthusiasts with a couple of them making handsome payments to have an experience of Dutch art and culture. The events are non restrictive as they allow Dutch artists all over the globe to participate and showcase their work.Aubameyang has now scored 30 goals this season for Dortmund. One truly needs to know that like anything else, there is a degree of service that also needs to be compared between the different businesses.
    Cheap Nike Jerseys

  30. Cheap China Jerseys

    Although fees are involved with listing items for sale and for selling items, most people find that the fees Ebay charges are warranted because of the number of shoppers the website consistently attracts.”Jerry, Kenny, Robin and I have had many conversations about ourobjectives in both the short and long term,” Rick Hahn said, referring to chairmanJerry Reinsdorf and executive VP Kenny Williams.You will likely have an more telephone range that is dedicated to your organization. Although fees are involved with listing items for sale and for selling items, most people find that the fees Ebay charges are warranted because of the number of shoppers the website consistently attracts. Think about them and you are surely to get your entrance to a big sales day.
    Cheap China Jerseys

  31. Cheap Jerseys From China

    Some other promotional sites are either less expensive or free, conversely none of them have enough web traffic to rival Ebay.Yedlin made just one substitute appearance for Tottenham following his move from Seattle. When you visit a camera shop, you will turn out to be confuse to find out a big variety of cameras before you. To help capitalize on the opportunity for earning money online, numerous people search for ways to make passive income.When you first join a message board or social networking site, take time to become familiar with the site and the people posting there.
    Cheap Jerseys From China

  32. Gianluigi Donnarumma Jersey

    You'll pay extra on top for these loans, but occasionally there is not any other option.** In the overlapping grip, you place the little finger of your trailing hand between the index and second finger of your lead hand. Before getting a high cost pay day loan, consider trying to borrow money from family or friends.”Understanding How Pay day Loans Work For YouUnderstanding How Pay day Loans Work For YouMarch 10, 2013Author: Yong KuoPosted in EducationEverybody has a surprising cost at one time or another, for example auto repairs or medical bills. A lot of things that can help you are available, you just need to increase the risk for first step.
    Gianluigi Donnarumma Jersey

  33. L. P. Ladouceur Jersey UK

    Create an industry specific commercial that also incorporates Doritos. Power strokes come from relaxed muscles and by gripping more with the fingers you will enjoy more dexterity in controlling the club and more refinement in your feel. It is actually not so new, as people have been running barefoot for hundreds of years.A Word About ShoesAn ill fitting shoe can be the cause of many lower extremity injuries.Choose Your Grip Type In order of popularity, there are 3 common grip types: Overlapping, Interlocking, and Ten Finger (a.
    L. P. Ladouceur Jersey UK

  34. Jacoby Brissett Jersey

    “It was bound to happen sometime. Switch if you are a leftie. Individuals who overpronate (rotate in) and have a flexible and flat foot type, typically need a more supportive shoe and sometimes a custom made orthotic.It is important to only use payday loan services if it's a necessity.com report.
    Jacoby Brissett Jersey

  35. samgong kartu

    Certainly you have got excellent ideas here and I love your site!

    I’ve bookmarked it ensuring that I can come back & continue reading
    later on.

  36. Sebastian Cristoforo Jersey

    There are different types of feet.Rugged Computer Lunchbox DesignRugged Portable Computer along with a Tiny ATX podium characteristics a multiple video slot, multiple drive fresh design in a stream lined property that gives high efficiency.** The ten finger grip is as it sounds, with 10 fingers in perfect contact with the handle.When looking at life insurance, do not purchase a lot more coverage than you actually demand.OppositionOpponents don ? t find these studies convincing and claim that these studies were too small or not carried out properly.
    Sebastian Cristoforo Jersey

  37. Micheal Azira Jersey

    These kind of lunchbox computers get the potential to utilize regular motherboards and also commercial backplanes with PCI e, typical PCI to ensure special enlargement cards can be included to the system. The body spends more energy when running in a shoe, than when running barefoot. A shoe that is too flexible may contribute to the development of plantar fasciitis (heel and arch pain).com report.Put plenty of time and thought into what you will give for company Christmas gifts.
    Micheal Azira Jersey

  38. qqpoker

    This is a superb blog, many thanks for sharing.

  39. Cheap Jerseys China

    So the competition let people do exactly that: do whatever they wanted to try and win a bit of beer.
    Cheap Jerseys China

  40. viagra without prescription

    viagra by mail order from canada
    viagra without prescription
    buy viagra discreetly

  41. myspace domains

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on myspace profile.


  42. ?i?n tho?i iphone hay b? t?t ngu?n

    Those manufacturers actually do not try to complement how big is the new phone with all the products.
    This handset gives a contemporary outlook and increases
    the personality of the person. I guess the coolest feature
    for this phone is the “All – Share”, because it’s a built-in handy remote control to make use of your Samsung TV.

  43. Torun

    Hello to every one, for the reason that I am truly eager of reading this weblog’s
    post to be updated daily. It consists of nice material.

  44. ?????? ??????? ???? ?????? ??????? ?????? ?????? ????? ????? ???? ?????? ???? ????? USB? ???? powerbank

    the ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

  45. Cheap Jerseys China Wholesale

    One of the the majority common ways of doing this is to monetize a webpage using advertisements. Be cautious, though, as you may not desire to fall prey to your frauds. One truly needs to know that like anything else, there is a degree of service that also needs to be compared between the different businesses. While you are researching your options, you may also want to talk to other single parents in the area. Being outside can create a peaceful environment and can also be quiet.

  46. ??

    I’ve been browsing online more than three hours today, yet
    I never discovered any attention-grabbing article like yours.
    It is lovely price sufficient for me. Personally, if all site owners and bloggers made excellent content as you did, the internet will probably be much more useful than ever before.

  47. M88

    Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist
    with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results.
    If you know of any please share. Thanks!

  48. Dorthy

    Its like you read my mind! You appear to know so much
    about this, like you wrote the book in it or something.
    I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but instead of that, this is magnificent blog.
    A fantastic read. I will certainly be back.

  49. Yorkshire Heritage Bus Company: vintage bus and coach hire

    There is noticeably a bundle to know about this. I assume you made certain nice points in features also.

  50. ????? ?? ???

    I find the crime and the attitude of the youth terrible!

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts