Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

A couple of weeks ago, we had an interesting lesson on the Fall of Mankind. A number of things were brought up that interested me. One was the difference between sin and transgression.

The way I see it, a transgression is the breaking of a law, while sin is knowingly breaking the law and willfully disobeying God. By this definition, a sin is a transgression, but a transgression isn’t necessarily a sin. This fits nicely with 1 John 3:4, which I’ve heard numerous times from those unfriendly to the Church to make out the Fall to be a horrible thing, something that we as a Church try to explain as something necessary and beautiful.  They were innocent (2 Nephi 2:23, Genesis 2:25), and therefore their transgression wasn’t so bad.

But my real question isn’t the degree to which Adam transgressed. My question is that which has been asked so many times before me; Why did God make the path to a necessary mortality through a transgression of the commandments of God?

Some have theorized that God was testing them to see if they would be obedient for a period of time, and that later he would command them to partake of the fruit.  This doesn’t make sense to me for a few of reasons: 1) Such a test wouldn’t seem to have any bearing on anything temporal or spiritual.  They still would have been required to enter the lone and dreary world where they would be subject to sin and temptation.  2) I don’t believe God would command someone to do something that would result in separation from him.  All of his commandments are designed to bring us closer.  3) A stronger argument than anything I could offer comes from 2 Nephi 2:22, where it seems to teach that if there had been no transgression, Adam and Eve would still be hanging out in the Garden of Eden.

I offer what I believe is the truer answer.  God knew that the experiences we needed to grow and become gods ourselves required a test of mortality and separation from God.  But by his own laws, he can’t simply remove himself from us.  We have to transgress to part from him.  He set up a law that could be broken in order for them to separate themselves.  Here’s the part that some might consider dangerous.  He allowed them to make a decision that put them in the fallen state necessary for growth via transgression.  Some may believe this to be borderline blasphemous.  I knew a missionary who put it this way: “It sounds like God set them up to get screwed.”  I don’t see it that way.

You see, God knows the beginning from the end.  He doesn’t ever command someone to sin, but he knows they’re going to do it.  So he uses others’ choices to further his own ends.  Take the crucifixion of Christ for example.  In 2 Nephi 10:3 it explains that it was necessary for Christ to live among the Jews, because they were the only ones wicked enough to crucify their Messiah.  He used the bad choices of others to complete his Son’s atonement.

But in the case of Adam and Eve, God didn’t even allow them to sin.  From certain scriptures (Moses 4:14, and others that seem to imply such), we know that children can trangress the law.  Heck, if you punish your 3-year old child for coloring on the wall, you know this.  They break the law, and there are temporal consequences, like time-out.  Nevertheless, they are innocent, and are therefore not eternally accountable for their decisions.  Adam and Eve’s innocence allowed them to pay for their decisions temporally (because it was merely transgression), and yet remain unstained from sin (see Moroni 8:8, 20, 22 that it still required Christ to atone for children, which he did because of their innocence).

Adam and Eve were innocent, and therefore they fulfilled God’s plan by transgressing the law, and yet God didn’t cause them to sin in the process.

I imagine that some readers (if I still have any after my absence) might have qualms with this doctrine.  I invite any comments, as this is a merely a question and a theoretical answer.

41,516 Responses to Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

  1. Cheap Jerseys USA

    Packers Brian Orakpo DE/LB Texas Brian Cushing Biggest and best of the hybrid edge defenders.
    Cheap Jerseys USA

  2. Sidney

    Hi there, I think your site might be having browser compatibility problems.
    Whenever I take a look at your blog in Safari, it looks fine however, if opening in I.E.,
    it’s got some overlapping issues. I just wanted to provide you with a quick heads up!

    Other than that, wonderful blog!

  3. karaoke nitip Kangen

    Have you ever thought about publishing an e-book or guest authoring on other blogs?
    I have a blog based on the same topics you discuss and would love to have you share some stories/information. I know my readers would appreciate
    your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to shoot me an email.

  4. free coffee samples

    My spouse and I stumbled over here coming from a different page and thought I might as well check things out.
    I like what I see so now i’m following you. Look forward to
    looking into your web page for a second time.

  5. http://www.sportsncaashop.com/Usc-Trojans-Sua-Cravens-Jerseys-Sale-49-Hd/

    With safety at our core, you will find no better provider of motorcycle training Wales or CBT Swansea and thus far, we are unrivalled on first time pass rate anywhere else in Wales. The instructors are all highly qualified and can teach a higher quality of English that can be applied to a lot of different facets of life. Modern technology and some brilliant minds have gifted us with such tools that fashion designing is not only made easier, but more efficient. This can ensure that you will know if you are banging on a locked door or even if she is prepared to let you within to her life. When you think about it three main components have to be in place: Trust and Predictability, competence, and sociability.

  6. Pete Rose Jersey

    With this figure, one can easily understand that nowadays no one buys a phone for just attending calls. Over time you will see that you’ve slowly constructed up your tools and that you’ve got progressed steadily towards increasingly more complex projects. There are no hidden fees and other discreet charges; you can get the greatest freedom you ever imagined in this business.Author Resource:-How to prepare for a modeling an interview with a modeling agency? Click here to know more about bubblegum casting. Especially with your current warm industry, they may know anyone in person and in addition they could possibly jeer thinking people finding myself a company.

  7. Mason Crosby Jersey

    From the fun games they play to teach the kids, to the efficient information for the adults, you will never go wrong using ESL Education for your business goals. If we have our children with us it shows not only are we happy to have them with us but also that we trust they will behave appropriately. With a Home windows laptop or computer procedure it’s often intelligent towards make a procedure maintenance stage ahead of putting in just about anything. Not only to students but also they are also able to teach English for Thai Teachers so that these teachers also will have the tools to then teach their students when ESL Education can not be present.C.
    Mason Crosby Jersey http://www.footballshopnfl.com/green-bay-packers-mason-crosby-jersey-sale/

  8. Cheap Jerseys Wholesale

    . Soft contacts are more comfortable than the porous lenses especially when it is inserted into your eye.com hvac index. Actually, fluid in the ears can easily cause a conductive loss of hearing. Actually, fluid in the ears can easily cause a conductive loss of hearing.

  9. zcoin

    Fascinating blog! Is your theme custom made or did you doownload it from somewhere?

    A theme like yours with a few simkple tweeks would really make
    myy blog stand out. Please let me know where you got your design. Thanks

  10. https://traffic4seo.com/

    I like what you guys are usually up too. This kind of clever work and exposure!
    Keep up the amazing works guys I’ve included you guys to our blogroll.

  11. Vinny Curry Jersey UK

    As a result of such misleading advices you have been subjected to loss of money as well as time and efforts.Marketing is one of the essential elements of business today.Hello Olympic Fans, My name is Warren from http://www.Innovative Ways to Use Digital LabelsDigital labels enable you to do things like add special offers to your labels. That’s exactly why it’s crucial that you occurs sponsor,part time,network or even anyone who to do a 3 means get in touch with with you.
    Vinny Curry Jersey UK http://www.thenflshopuk.com/Philadelphia-Eagles-Vinny-Curry-Jersey/

  12. Cheap Jerseys From China

    The life of you and your family also affected by moving because if you have kids at home, they have to change their school if the new place is so far from their school and other family members’ workplace may also be so far from new living place. We can be wiser, greater, a lot quicker, and much stronger. Prospects can choose a primary coverage which covers between 6 and 10 illnesses or a complete cowl which lined as much as 30 illnesses. This can also give your children a much better concept of just what the planet is very like. It enables both partners to maintain and kiss for the whole time when in sexual intercourse.

  13. Cheap Nike NFL Jerseys Sale

    Over time the variety of diseases has broadened rapidly resulting from medical advances. You can easily read what other folks have said about a particular brand name, and you can determine if you wish to purchase that one or go with something else. I saved forty. It is also a good idea to figure out which element of your wedding is most important to you and make sure that you get that element. Then U.

  14. free coffee samples

    Does your website have a contact page? I’m having problems
    locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an e-mail. I’ve got some creative ideas for your blog you might be
    interested in hearing. Either way, great blog and I look forward to seeing it expand
    over time.

  15. http://www.sportsnhlshop.com/Edmonton-Oilers-Nail-Yakupov-Jersey-Sale/

    Offset business cards are the best way to create an impression with the dealers, mergers, business associates, and other people in the course of business. That they like to talk about their problems, and many of the time they just want someone who listens to all of them. The mini dishwasher bosch comes at the most affordable prices. There are lots of strategies towards choose contaminated with malware. Remember visit my website for more similar related articles.
    http://www.sportsnhlshop.com/Edmonton-Oilers-Nail-Yakupov-Jersey-Sale/ http://www.sportsnhlshop.com/Edmonton-Oilers-Nail-Yakupov-Jersey-Sale/

  16. Javier Pastore Argentina Jersey

    Offset business cards are the best way to create an impression with the dealers, mergers, business associates, and other people in the course of business. Be sure to know what you want as well as how to get it. Problem is, when you visit them to discuss YOUR CBT Swansea, they fail to deliver; their rates are sky high and they cannot begin your motorcycle training Wales when you want it; right NOW!Welcome to Two Wheels Motorcycle Training Wales. Keep a lookout for them. The quality printing gives the business cards a fresh look that is unbeatable with time and thus one should get them printed from the best printing services available and if possible than eddm printing service.
    Javier Pastore Argentina Jersey http://www.theworldsoccershop.com/ARGENTINA-JAVIER-PASTORE-JERSEY/

  17. cphtcbtefm

    the ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments
    cphtcbtefm http://www.gnhl8056j3qmh2o2mvcrl572092x24j0s.org/

  18. brptigzjc

    the ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments
    brptigzjc http://www.gv2u5901022l0cqjo5x0hn0y1z2dt41ws.org/

  19. Cheap Jerseys Wholesale

    Moreover, we are emerging unswervingly in the field and just target at achieving a solo goal of conquering total client satisfaction. Certificates are not as practical for your customer to always be carrying around with them, while Playing cards effortlessly fit with your clients Financial institution Playing cards and Credit Playing cards. Moogo is perfect for individuals, small businesses, clubs and organizations, sport teams, real estate. Of course, if you have a little bit more money to spend, you can upgrade your dirt cheap wedding to include a wedding bouquet, some wedding music, and a couple of photographs of you getting married. Once your coronary heart desires something, you may normally look for approaches to meet all those desires.

  20. Wholesale Nike NFL Jerseys

    This is a good way to get modern style home. Every agricultural branch needs time invested and resources, but it is highly rewarding in the end when you get to see the results of your work. These heavy gauge materials prevent warping of fan parts and malfunction at high temperatures. They are prerequisites for artists and other performers.If you get extra space within your existing home, why you need a larger home? It is advisable, if you get functional room by using unused space of your existing home wisely.

  21. zanaflex

    You actually make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this
    topic to be really something that I think I would never understand.
    It seems too complicated and extremely broad for me.

    I’m looking forward for your next post, I’ll try to
    get the hang of it!

  22. Cheap NFL Jerseys Free Shipping

    There are accessible online website wizard which does not require technical skills but just follow the step by step guide.There’s additionally differences in the sort of cowl with some other protection insurance policies on the market today. Sometimes stuff appear to be so overpowering that you simply truly feel hopeless. Try hosting your wedding dinner at one of the many restaurants that are all over Las Vegas. Website building can be a tough process for those of us who don’t have an awesome relationship with their computer.

  23. free movie

    I blog quite often and I seriously thank you for your information. This
    great article has really peaked my interest. I will bookmark
    your website and keep checking for new information about once per week.
    I opted in for your RSS feed too.

  24. gdpr foundation course london

    I think everything posted made a lot of sense. But, what about this?
    what if you composed a catchier title? I am not suggesting your content is not good, but suppose
    you added something that grabbed a person’s attention? I mean the
    ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments
    is kinda vanilla. You could look at Yahoo’s front page and watch how they create
    news titles to get viewers to click. You might add a related video or a pic
    or two to grab people excited about everything’ve got to say.
    In my opinion, it might make your blog a little bit more interesting.

  25. www.wayseit.com

    Excellent blog here! Also your website loads up very fast!
    What web host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link
    to your host? I wish my site loaded up as fast as
    yours lol

  26. Parajumpers outlet

    I was just looking for this information for quite a while. Almost one and a half hours of continuous surfing, luckily I saw that in your blog. I dont understand why Bing never display this sort of good websites in the first page. Usually the top web sites are full of junks. Perhaps it is time to use other search engine.
    Parajumpers outlet

  27. naijasquare

    whoah this weblog is magnificent i love reading your posts.
    Stay up the great work! You understand, a lot of persons are searching around for this info, you
    can aid them greatly.

  28. offre ouverture compte boursorama

    I am sure this article has touched all the internet visitors, its really really
    nice article on building up new blog.

  29. site

    You really make it seem really easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be actually one thing that I feel I’d by
    no means understand. It sort of feels too complicated and extremely wide for me.
    I am having a look ahead for your next publish, I will try to get the cling
    of it!

  30. fitness

    Do you have a spam issue on this site; I also
    am a blogger, and I was wondering your situation; many
    of us have developed some nice procedures and we are looking to swap methods with other folks, be sure to shoot
    me an e-mail if interested.

  31. Cody Franson Jersey

    It is a training method designed to develop a horse’s natural abilities and responsiveness to instructions from the rider. You can make a dishwasher comparison and then choose the one that suits your needs best. Designers italiens se trouvent ?tre connus pour recourir ? des mat?riaux pour obtenir de la plus grande qualit? aui puisse ?tre et le proc?d? de ex?cution se compose habituellement pour obtenir activit? minutieux. Publications and newspapers contain them, and your self can lower or tear them out. For this reason your organization stresses employing a few technique message or calls, they know they will perform.

  32. ciré femme

    After I originally commented I seem to havve clicked on the -Notify me when new comments are
    added- checkbox and froim now on every time a comment is added I recieve four emaiuls with the same comment.
    Is there a means you can remove me from tthat service?
    Many thanks!

  33. http://www.ncaasportsshop.com/Texas-Longhorns-Tristian-Houston-Jersey/

    In most cases of legal pursuits for redemption and reimbursements there is a deadline within which a case needs to be filed.In 2015 alone, over 1 billion smartphones were sold to the users worldwide.Whenever you need a new program or business model to get your foot out the global door, be sure to turn towards ESL Education. DropshipHerbalSupplements.Dressage is often referred to as ‘horse ballet’.

  34. http://www.thenhlhockeyshop.com/Buffalo-Sabres-Johan-Larsson-Jersey/

    With this figure it can be easily said that the app industry has not come to leave the arena, instead it has come to stay and rule. See how a Whole Fitness Personal Trainer can help you, at Total Fitness. Wide availability of digital labels since the 1990s has made it much easier for firms to get their packaging right. It’s okay to do it your way. Phew! That is a major growth.

  35. Custom Detroit Lions Jersey

    Let me just assure you that if your child has self-confidence, self-reliance, and self-control then self-esteem comes naturally. For instance, you can register with the program offered by DropshipHerbalSupplements. We have been entrusted with the care and upbringing of a diabetic child.united kingdom today. Taking the time to find a firm that has a good reputation, and has been in the business for some time, will save time, money and hassle.
    Custom Detroit Lions Jersey

  36. http://www.sportsnflshop.com/Miami-Dolphins-Kiko-Alonso-Jersey-Sale/

    populationAnother fact that will help you in believing that mobile apps will make it to the Everest is the fact that by 2016 per person will have 1. As English grows more and more, you will need to be able to compete with other companies that can speak English and do so effectively. In fact over recent years the number of women competing has dramatically increased with around 80 percent of the competitors now being female.4 million (56%); however venues and sports grounds also received a substantial portion with $410. It is expected that more than 1 billion mobile units will be sold next year.

  37. Clement Simonin Jersey UK

    61% of these mobile users will own a smartphone.Marketing is one of the essential elements of business today. Event horses have to be at the peak of physical fitness as do their riders – they are the decathletes of the equine world.The time has arrived for you to start on your journey to successful motorcycle training Wales or CBT Swansea where you can learn all the vital aspects of safe, road worthy motorcycle riding but you’ve reached a stumbling block. They have the best solutions for research, weight loss, fashion, consultancy and applications.
    Clement Simonin Jersey UK

  38. http://www.sportssoccershop.com/England-Dele-Alli-Soccer-Jersey-Sale/

    Getting Your Digital Labels RightIf you do decide to go with digital labels, the printing firm you use is important. Legal firms can offer the expertise and consultation of a professional negligence lawyer if you approach them for the same. You have the possibility that you find a girl that shows her attraction to you, and tells you that she likes you. The Eddm printing service is the right choice for people who are looking to get a printing of their menus for restaurants, hotels or cafes done.g.

  39. Torey Krug Jersey

    Offset business cards are the best way to create an impression with the dealers, mergers, business associates, and other people in the course of business. Although this is a very important factor, a warning is given to models especially ladies that they must be very careful with such agencies because some of these are just there to consider advantage of the model and never to help them. Author Resource:-Insights On Effective Techniques In Antivirus Net Protection 2015 can give you greatest details for An Analysis Of Core Factors In Antivirus Online World Safety 2010.Some MLM Signing up Ways To Have Got An Effective Contact. La mise en place ainsi votre portabilit? d’une chaussure authentique Gucci et aussi Prada se r?v?le ?tre in?gal?e et a la facult? de facilement se pr?senter comme d?termin?e avec un tantinet de activit? d’investigation.
    Torey Krug Jersey

  40. Courtney Lee Jersey UK

    Once you have determined what undertaking you’ll do, take a look at the materials and tools you will want for it. It contains never ever been as a result basic towards reach the obtain Android Marketplace application. I hope it was of interest to you as it is to me. In Thailand, there are quite a few places that you can go to in order to learn English. Getting used to being in new situations, and learning to talk to different people will increase our children’s confidence considerably.
    Courtney Lee Jersey UK

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts