Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

A couple of weeks ago, we had an interesting lesson on the Fall of Mankind. A number of things were brought up that interested me. One was the difference between sin and transgression.

The way I see it, a transgression is the breaking of a law, while sin is knowingly breaking the law and willfully disobeying God. By this definition, a sin is a transgression, but a transgression isn’t necessarily a sin. This fits nicely with 1 John 3:4, which I’ve heard numerous times from those unfriendly to the Church to make out the Fall to be a horrible thing, something that we as a Church try to explain as something necessary and beautiful.  They were innocent (2 Nephi 2:23, Genesis 2:25), and therefore their transgression wasn’t so bad.

But my real question isn’t the degree to which Adam transgressed. My question is that which has been asked so many times before me; Why did God make the path to a necessary mortality through a transgression of the commandments of God?

Some have theorized that God was testing them to see if they would be obedient for a period of time, and that later he would command them to partake of the fruit.  This doesn’t make sense to me for a few of reasons: 1) Such a test wouldn’t seem to have any bearing on anything temporal or spiritual.  They still would have been required to enter the lone and dreary world where they would be subject to sin and temptation.  2) I don’t believe God would command someone to do something that would result in separation from him.  All of his commandments are designed to bring us closer.  3) A stronger argument than anything I could offer comes from 2 Nephi 2:22, where it seems to teach that if there had been no transgression, Adam and Eve would still be hanging out in the Garden of Eden.

I offer what I believe is the truer answer.  God knew that the experiences we needed to grow and become gods ourselves required a test of mortality and separation from God.  But by his own laws, he can’t simply remove himself from us.  We have to transgress to part from him.  He set up a law that could be broken in order for them to separate themselves.  Here’s the part that some might consider dangerous.  He allowed them to make a decision that put them in the fallen state necessary for growth via transgression.  Some may believe this to be borderline blasphemous.  I knew a missionary who put it this way: “It sounds like God set them up to get screwed.”  I don’t see it that way.

You see, God knows the beginning from the end.  He doesn’t ever command someone to sin, but he knows they’re going to do it.  So he uses others’ choices to further his own ends.  Take the crucifixion of Christ for example.  In 2 Nephi 10:3 it explains that it was necessary for Christ to live among the Jews, because they were the only ones wicked enough to crucify their Messiah.  He used the bad choices of others to complete his Son’s atonement.

But in the case of Adam and Eve, God didn’t even allow them to sin.  From certain scriptures (Moses 4:14, and others that seem to imply such), we know that children can trangress the law.  Heck, if you punish your 3-year old child for coloring on the wall, you know this.  They break the law, and there are temporal consequences, like time-out.  Nevertheless, they are innocent, and are therefore not eternally accountable for their decisions.  Adam and Eve’s innocence allowed them to pay for their decisions temporally (because it was merely transgression), and yet remain unstained from sin (see Moroni 8:8, 20, 22 that it still required Christ to atone for children, which he did because of their innocence).

Adam and Eve were innocent, and therefore they fulfilled God’s plan by transgressing the law, and yet God didn’t cause them to sin in the process.

I imagine that some readers (if I still have any after my absence) might have qualms with this doctrine.  I invite any comments, as this is a merely a question and a theoretical answer.

34,709 Responses to Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments

  1. http://essaywritingpaper.info/

    If you’re inclikned on concepts of life and death then you can certainly find
    different designs available at tattoo galleries. Then wwe fast forward fve weeks and Amelia actually
    starts to doubt there’s smething wrong using the baby.
    Hilary Duff also became a singer from beinng
    merely a star of her Disnbey Channel show, Lizzie Maguire.

  2. pxmpzln

    the ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments
    pxmpzln http://www.gzcmho711m9r240zd825390v2o9d4dots.org/

  3. ???????????

    2? ????1.?????????????????????????????????????????? ???PeterEnglisch???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????3000??????????????????????????5000???????????1500????????2000???????????????????

  4. yjsshrngr

    the ladder » Blog Archive » Falls, Sins, Transgressions, Commandments
    yjsshrngr http://www.g79xgt5l871u4a5k4mo6g6nx75kx545ws.org/

  5. www.wikispaces.com

    I read this article completely concerning the difference
    of most recent and preceding technologies, it’s awesome

  6. Best Apps for Android Mobile Phone

    I assume this is amongst the so a lot essential information and facts for me.And i’m pleased learning your posting. Thanks in support of sharing these a pleasant thought, piece of composing is awesome, thats why i have browse it completely,if you want to find more best android apps and download android apps for free ,please click on here.

  7. Cheap NFL Jerseys Online

    There will be problems along the way, but with determination, you can make it through and do what you have to. This bubbly pleasurable auto is the least complicated decision for these intrigued inside judicious gasoline overall economy and as a result that they can determination the distances their center requirements without having getting in direction of tension regarding gasoline.Whenever your renovation or renovation venture is large enough, you will likely be using a basic service provider, who can have sub companies working for him consequently. Spyware is not a virus, consequently antivirus software program will hardly ever determine it.New Opportunities For Nursing CareersAs the shortage continues to develop, nurses (particularly experienced, well trained nurses) will enjoy some of the safest, most recession proof positions in the industry.

  8. Best Apps for Android Mobile Phone

    I imagine this is amongst the so a lot significant facts for me.And i’m pleased learning your post. Thanks in aid of sharing these kinds of a nice assumed, piece of producing is awesome, thats why i have examine it completely,if you want to find more best android apps and download android apps for free ,remember to click below.
    Best Apps for Android Mobile Phone

  9. ???????????????????

    Hello, Neat post. There is an issue together with your web site in internet explorer, might test this?

    IE nonetheless is the marketplace leader and a big part of people will leave out your magnificent writing because of this

  10. Best Apps for Android Mobile Phone

    I think this is amongst the so a great deal critical details for me.And i’m contented researching your write-up. Many thanks in support of sharing these a wonderful believed, piece of composing is good, thats why i have study it completely,if you want to find more best android apps and download android apps for free ,make sure you click here.

  11. ???????,???????????

    153??????? 154?????????

  12. curso de sublimação em bh

    I all the time emailed this web site post page to all my friends, since if
    like to read it then my links will too.

  13. Cleveland

    Apprec?ate ?t for h??ping out, superb information.

  14. ?????????,???????,pjbet111?????

    257????? 258??????????169?????(?????????)

  15. ??????,????????,??????

    35?????????? 36????????????????????

  16. ???

    I am really impressed together with your writing skills as neatly as with
    the format to your weblog. Is this a paid subject matter
    or did you customize it your self? Anyway stay
    up the excellent high quality writing, it is uncommon to peer a great blog
    like this one today..

  17. Sang

    Hi there to every one, because I am genuinely keen of reading
    this website’s post to be updated on a regular basis.
    It carries nice data.

  18. ?????????,???????????,???????

    15??????? 16???????32?????

  19. bupropionn.science

    I don’t even know the way I finished up right here, however
    I thought this post was once great. I do not recognise who you’re but
    certainly you are going to a well-known blogger in case you are not already.


  20. Cheapest Newark Ca Dentist

    I absolutely love your blog and find most of your post’s to be exactly I’m looking for.
    Do you offer guest writers to write content in your case?

    I wouldn’t mind creating a post or elaborating on some of the
    subjects you write related to here. Again, awesome site!

  21. ????? ???

    I really like your articles. Very fascinating hub.

  22. Football Strike Hack Iphone

    You ought to be a part of a contest for one of the highest quality
    sites on the internet. I most certainly will recommend this site!

  23. Umanizzare presidios

    Hello there! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after browsing through many of the articles I realized it’s new to me. Anyways, I’m certainly delighted I discovered it and I’ll be book-marking it and checking back frequently!|

  24. Hair loss prevention

    Most of them are fatal but the saddest fact is that most of them are preventable.

    Liver, meat, onions and other foods are prone to
    excessive acidic toxins in the blood, so you should eat less.
    Moreover, the function of double visor helmets is not only
    limited to facilitating ventilation, but they effectively act as the rider’s sunglasses too.

  25. shearing

    Hi my loved one! I want to say that this article is awesome,
    nice written and include almost all vital infos. I’d like to see
    extra posts like this .

  26. vidmate app download

    You¡¯re in reality a excellent webmaster.The web site loading velocity is incredible. It seems that you are doing any distinctive trick. Furthermore, The contents are masterwork.you¡¯ve done a excellent process in this subject!Vidmate app download and vidmate apps download here for free£¡

  27. ????? ????

    Virtually everything that was mentioned was not true.

  28. ??????,???????,???????????!,????????

    65??????????? 66???????

  29. ?8??,?8????pt???,long8cc??,??8?????

    73??????? 74????????

  30. ????????,????????,??????????

    165?????????????? 166???????

  31. ???????,???????,???????????

    11??????????? 12?????????????

  32. Cheap Jerseys Free Shipping

    Nonetheless, one need to be cautious while trying to leverage jailbreaking services. If oneself comprise any of such indications, or if your laptop out of the blue prevents functioning effectively, scan your pc with antivirus software program. When hospitals are short staffed, they lose money as they unstaffed units close, experience a higher nurse turnover, and, according to a study conducted by the University of Pennsylvania, an increase of as much as 31% in patient death. Taking the minimum requirements, the plant will form seeds or spores . All work is guaranteed.

  33. ???????

    2? ???????????????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????? ?????????????? LTD ??

  34. José Wilame Araújo Rodrigues

    Quality content is the crucial to attract the people to pay a quick visit the website, that’s what this web page is providing.|

Leave a Reply

Recent Posts